Germany, Europe’s largest economy, is still grappling with structural challenges as it braces for a second consecutive year of contraction.
Economic forecasts for 2024 now project a 0.2% decline in gross domestic product (GDP), following a 0.3% drop in 2023.
This marks the first back-to-back recession since the reunification of East and West Germany in 1990.
The economic downturn is compounded by structural issues, including a struggling manufacturing sector, increasing competition from China, and unresolved energy concerns.
Many are now questioning whether these issues are temporary or deep-rooted.
The Decline of a Global Powerhouse
Germany’s current economic struggles have been long in the making.
The manufacturing sector, traditionally the backbone of the German economy, has been hit particularly hard.
The Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) plummeted to 40.6 in September 2024, marking its 27th consecutive month of contraction.
This is the second-lowest reading globally, behind only Myanmar, indicating a severe downturn in industrial activity.
The decline is largely driven by a prolonged slump in export orders, which has been unprecedented in recent decades.
Source: Bloomberg
Competition from China has emerged as a significant factor affecting key sectors like automotive and mechanical engineering.
Known as the “China shock,” this challenge has made it difficult for German manufacturers to compete, especially as China continues to dominate markets for electric vehicles (EVs) and industrial machinery.
With automakers like Volkswagen warning of potential factory closures and Tesla’s European factory seeing unsold inventory, the auto industry’s challenges reflect broader issues across the industrial base.
Adding to these difficulties, Germany’s energy crisis has been exacerbated by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which disrupted gas supplies and drove energy prices up.
Although inflation has eased in recent months—falling to 1.6% in September 2024—energy costs remain a concern for both households and industries, weighing heavily on the nation’s competitiveness.
Is government intervention enough to spark recovery?
In response to these challenges, the German government, led by Economy Minister Robert Habeck, has introduced a series of measures aimed at stabilizing the economy.
These include a growth package consisting of 49 reforms intended to stimulate private and public investment, enhance productivity, and address longstanding structural problems.
The package focuses on reducing bureaucratic red tape, expanding renewable energy, and providing tax relief to spur consumer spending.
The government is also revising its inflation forecast, expecting the rate to fall to 2.2% in 2024, down from 5.9% in 2023.
By 2026, inflation is anticipated to stabilize at 1.9%. Falling inflation rates, coupled with rising wages and tax cuts, are seen as key to reviving private consumption and driving economic growth in the coming years.
The administration projects a return to modest growth of 1.1% in 2025 and 1.6% in 2026.
However, the success of these measures hinges on their timely and effective implementation.
Habeck has stressed that full support from both houses of parliament, including the opposition-controlled Bundesrat, is necessary for the reforms to take effect.
If successful, these initiatives could lay the groundwork for stronger economic performance and higher employment levels.
Yet, skepticism remains, with some economists and industry leaders arguing that the measures are insufficient to address the deep-rooted issues weighing on the economy.
Maybe Germany’s issues are deeply rooted
Germany’s economic challenges go beyond short-term cyclical downturns; they are deeply structural.
The country’s reliance on traditional industries, such as automotive manufacturing and chemical production, is being tested in an era of rapid technological and geopolitical change.
Decarbonization, digitalization, and demographic shifts are pressing concerns that need to be addressed if Germany is to regain its competitive edge.
Decarbonization efforts have been accelerated by the energy crisis, with a push towards renewable energy to reduce dependency on fossil fuels.
Yet, this transition has not been smooth, with energy costs for businesses still significantly higher than in other industrialized nations.
According to the DIHK industry lobby, companies in Germany pay four times as much for electricity, including taxes and fees, compared to rivals abroad, hampering their global competitiveness.
Digitalization also remains a challenge.
Despite Germany’s reputation for engineering excellence, the country has lagged behind in adopting advanced digital technologies, particularly in its small and mid-sized enterprises.
This digital gap is seen as a barrier to increasing productivity and modernizing industries that are essential for future growth.
Demographic factors further complicate the situation.
An aging population and a shortage of skilled workers threaten the long-term sustainability of the labor market.
With fewer young people entering the workforce, companies face difficulties in filling positions, especially in highly technical fields like engineering and information technology.
Are companies looking for an exit strategy?
As Germany grapples with domestic challenges, many companies are increasingly looking abroad for growth opportunities or are becoming targets for foreign acquisitions.
The recent €14 billion sale of Deutsche Bahn’s logistics subsidiary Schenker to Danish company DSV illustrates this trend.
Additionally, Commerzbank, the country’s second-largest private lender, is seen as a potential takeover target, with Italian banking giant UniCredit raising its stake to 21%.
The chemical giant BASF is also pursuing international expansion, investing €10 billion in a new factory in China, signaling a shift towards markets with higher growth potential.
These strategic moves highlight the difficulties businesses face in the domestic market and the need for German companies to diversify to stay competitive.
An Uncertain Path Forward
The future of Germany’s economy remains uncertain, with several key factors determining whether the country can bounce back.
The government’s growth forecasts for 2025 and 2026 offer some optimism, but achieving these targets will depend on the successful implementation of structural reforms and stabilization of the global economic environment.
The German economy is likely to experience a slow and uneven recovery, with private consumption, boosted by falling inflation and wage increases, playing a crucial role.
Still, deeper reforms are needed to address the root causes of the country’s economic stagnation. Without tackling energy costs, digitalization, and labor shortages, Germany risks falling further behind other advanced economies.
While structural problems are evident, they also provide a chance for the country to rethink its growth strategy, modernize industries, and embrace innovation.
As the government works to implement reforms, the coming years will be critical in determining whether Germany can reclaim its status as Europe’s economic powerhouse or continue to struggle with stagnation.
The post Is Germany’s economy doomed or can structural reforms revive growth? appeared first on Invezz
