The Trump administration is facing a potential financial nightmare that could cost the Treasury massively in tariff refunds, depending on how the Supreme Court rules on a case that’s making its way through the courts right now.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent laid out the stakes pretty bluntly during a recent “Meet the Press” interview, warning that if the Supreme Court invalidates Trump’s tariffs, the government will have to cut massive refund checks to importers who paid those duties.
The numbers are staggering as we are talking about refunding roughly half of all tariffs collected under what Trump called his “reciprocal” tariff program.
Billions hang in legal balance
This mess started with an August 29 ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which decided 7-4 that most of Trump’s tariffs were illegal because they exceeded presidential authority under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act.
That 1977 law gives the president emergency economic powers to deal with national security threats, but the appeals court said Trump stretched that authority way beyond what Congress intended.
Now the Supreme Court is being asked to settle the question, and the Trump administration is pushing for an expedited review to clarify just how much tariff power the president actually has.
The timing matters because Bessent warned that delays could make things even worse as if the Court doesn’t rule until mid-2026, the government might collect another trillion dollars in tariffs before having to reverse course and pay it all back.
The legal battle goes beyond just money. It’s really about the balance of power between Congress and the executive branch when it comes to trade policy.
If the Supreme Court upholds the lower court’s decision, it could seriously restrict how future presidents use emergency powers for economic measures.
But if they side with Trump, it gives the presidency robust authority to impose tariffs under emergency powers, which would shape trade policy for years to come.
Exports and supply chains in flux
The ripple effects extend far beyond US borders too. Countries that got hit hardest by these tariffs with Canada, Mexico, China, and India are watching closely since the ruling could dramatically change their export costs and duties.
Indian textile, jewelry, and engineering exporters are particularly hoping for relief from what they’ve considered punitive tariffs.
For businesses, the uncertainty is creating planning headaches.
Companies that have been paying these tariffs and passing costs along to consumers don’t know whether to expect refunds or continued high duties.
Supply chains that adapted to the tariff environment might have to readjust again depending on the Court’s decision.
The government has been using tariff revenue to help fund tax cuts and spending programs, so having to pay back hundreds of billions would create a significant fiscal hole that would need to be filled somehow.
The post Supreme Court ruling could force Trump tariff refunds worth billions, warns Bessent appeared first on Invezz
